October 16, 2023
We settled into our usual pew for the 5:00 PM Saturday Mass, surrounded by senior citizens. We were part of the surrounding. It’s the same at the early Sunday Mass. Mainly old folks, just the way it is. Maybe the young ones come later.
We didn’t know it then, but Hamas terrorists already had started their attacks on Israel, murdering hundreds of civilians. Israel, the Holy Land, the birthplace of the three Abrahamic religions, has again become a bloodbath.
Individuals may endure private agonies of spiritual doubt. In the Middle East, religious conflict eternally tortures nations and communities. Disagreement and discord translate to fundamentalism and fanaticism. That is going on now in America, as “evangelical” Christians campaign for extremist Republicans, while so-called “traditionalist” Catholics attack the Pope.
Religious acrimony, sometimes as small-minded pettiness, shows up in strange places. Our daughter is a graduate of Belmont Abbey College in Belmont, N.C. So is Republican Rep. Patrick McHenry (N.C.) who became speaker “pro tempore” of the House of Representatives last week. The college president sent an email asking for prayers for McHenry. This was just after McHenry expelled the former speaker, Democrat Nancy Pelosi, from her office. No prayers for Pelosi, though.
So Mass started, we stood, Father Steve approached the altar. He’s the new priest, a humble guy who will laugh at himself. A week or so ago he began his sermon by talking about the U.S. Tennis Open. I don’t recall any connection to the Gospel. Sometimes I nod off. Sandy nudges me, I open my eyes and try to listen.
The tennis metaphor was unique. I guessed he looks to grab the audience with an offbeat, attention-getting opening. More priests need to do the same.
He talked about the Gospel (Matthew, chapter 21, verses 33-43), the one about Jesus debating the Pharisees and Scribes, the officials who controlled nearly every aspect of Jewish life at the time. Jesus describes a landowner who planted a vineyard and leased it to tenants. When he sent his servants to receive the grapes, the tenants killed them. A second delegation of servants also were killed. The owner then sent his son, the tenants also murdered him.
Jesus asks, “What will the owner do to those tenants?” The answer is, he’ll put them to death and lease the vineyard to others who will surrender the grapes at the proper time. Jesus then says to the Pharisees, “Therefore I say to you, the kingdom of God will be taken away from you and given to people who will produce its fruit.”
Father Steve wrapped up, saying, “Jesus is challenging the Pharisees, calling them out, because he sees through their hypocrisy in using legalisms and empty rules to maintain their authority.”
I heard something different. This humble priest in this modest parish in Upstate South Carolina was talking about present-day Pharisees and Scribes. He was challenging the Catholic cardinals and bishops who think they know Pope Francis’s job better than he does. These are the leaders who for decades covered up the church’s sex scandal and fail, even now, to communicate the truth of Christ’s message, while Catholics young and old abandon the Church.
Last week Pope Francis opened his “Synod of Bishops,” a conference of 450 bishops that is examining the future of the Catholic Church. On the agenda are tough questions: the place of LGBTQ persons in Catholicism, increased decision-making authority for women and lay people in the Church, and the still-simmering crisis of sexual abuse by priests.
As the Synod started, Francis wrote, “This is the primary task of the Synod: to refocus our gaze on God, to be a church that looks mercifully at humanity.” Meanwhile five so-called “conservative” cardinals sent pointed questions to Francis challenging him on his teaching. Francis deftly turned the questions aside, as Christ answered the Pharisees who tried to trap him.
Then last week Francis said, unambiguously, “Israel has a right to defend itself. I pray for those families who saw a feast day turned into a day of mourning, and I ask that the hostages be immediately released.”
Through his ten years as Pope, Francis has communicated Christ’s message of compassion. That means looking beyond rigid doctrine. The so-called traditionalist cardinals, bishops, and others have relentlessly criticized him, called him a heretic and worse.

Francis hasn’t tried to overturn or ignore Catholic teaching on abortion, marriage, and sin. But he preaches that Christ never used legalisms or doctrine as a weapon.
The “traditionalists” are outraged at that. In August 2020 a priest from La Crosse, Wisc., Father James Altman, posted a video saying Francis has excommunicated himself. His bishop banned him from saying Mass. In 2021 Altman led the opening prayer at the right-wing Conservative Political Action Conference. Several bishops and actor Mel Gibson defended him.
Francis challenged the cardinals and bishops who attacked him, calling them backward-looking and reactionary. “Instead of living by the true doctrine that always develops and bears fruit, they live by ideologies,” he said.
Francis has not achieved everything he tried. When elected he promised “zero tolerance” for sexual abuse. But cases still show up. In February 2019 he convened a church summit on sexual abuse that produced no policy decisions.
I tracked down Father Steve after the Mass. I said, “I hope those angry cardinals don’t come after you.” He smiled and said something like, “yeah, there’s a parallel between the Pharisees and the people attacking the pope. That’s how I look at it.”
He added, “some of these issues are confusing. But the Holy Father is leading us to follow the teachings of Christ.”
In 2015 I stood in a crowd of maybe 25,000 below the Capitol to hear Francis speak after he had addressed a joint session of Congress. The cheers were deafening. At that moment he was a star. That was before the “traditionalists” or “conservatives” went after him.
Meanwhile the Israelis are bombing Hamas hideouts into rubble. The present-day Pharisees are looking for ammunition. Francis still is seeking, for all of us, the peace of Christ.









