November 29, 2021
Because the Thanksgiving weekend is a benchmark for retail success or failure, stores deploy Christmas inventories, decorations, lights, and artificial trees in October, some in September. Two days out, we crawled toward the holiday by getting groceries and stringing Christmas lights in the afternoon chill.
We worked this year to salvage some authentic sense of the season, just the two of us in our place in the burbs in this northwest corner of South Carolina. The big get-togethers of past years still are problematic. Nearly one-third of Americans are unvaccinated. Experts have found a new variant, omicron, probably coming our way.
The idea of Thanksgiving as a day for family togetherness and good cheer, big meals, football, acts of charity, is still on the books. It recalls the elegiac Feast of the Pilgrims at Plymouth Colony in 1621, the start of a tradition eventually recognized by Presidents and official proclamations. A little research reveals that nearly all of the Pilgrims present were men, most of the women who arrived at Plymouth died in the first year. The local Wampanoag tribesmen who showed up outnumbered the Pilgrims two-to-one.
Many are thankful for the precious things, family connections, good health, and such prosperity as we may enjoy. Good health is a special gift these days. Some don’t have those things, we know that by looking around. We see, in this time of abundance, people who suffer, who look to the rest of us for a reason to give thanks. The U.S. Department of Agriculture reports that 10.5 percent of U.S. households (13.8 million) were “food insecure” in 2020. Everywhere in America good people write checks for charity and show up at churches and soup kitchens to serve Thanksgiving meals.
Years, no—decades ago, at our little place near downtown Nashville, Sandy and I were in the habit of inviting someone in the neighborhood, usually someone we barely knew, for Thanksgiving dinner. We weren’t doing anything special. We had room at the table. The folks we invited weren’t especially in need, just at loose ends. We toasted the day and ate and talked about everything, past, present, future. We then said goodnight and “Happy Thanksgiving.” Those brief hours were un-self-consciously full of good cheer. In time we moved beyond that as the kids grew and relatives would drift over. Now it seems so long ago. It is.
The power of Thanksgiving is, or should be, its sublime transcendence. We give thanks, those who do, most directly through prayer, which ought to seem self-evident. Give thanks for this or that—to whom, or what? The impulse to thank the Lord on some particular autumn day came from churchgoers, who understood that no matter how strong their faith, they still had to hunt game and work their rude acreages, as the Wampanoags taught them, to ward off starvation. Yet it was faith that brought them to that Massachusetts wilderness.
The years sped by, we stumbled into the mid-1980s and landed in New Jersey. Life got complicated. It seems, maybe only in my hazy memory, that the cataclysms of those years in business, politics, technology, everything else, distracted us about Thanksgiving, or distracted me. We bought our first computer in 1987 for $4,000, heavy as an anchor with a tiny fraction of the power of your cell phone. Just after Thanksgiving I visited a half-dozen stores looking for a Cabbage Patch doll. The relief I felt when I found one, at a J.C. Penney’s just as the place opened—indescribable.
After one year in Jersey we landed in Virginia. Thanksgivings and Christmases then blurred together for us and for the world around us. The kids grew up and left home, the Thanksgiving ritual became a frantic scramble, one or two of them getting home, the others creating their own holidays. Retail Thanksgiving loomed. One year we all made it to our son Michael’s and daughter-in-law Caroline’s place near Philly. On Black Friday Sandy and the girls rose at 3:00 AM and headed for the mall. They were home with packages by dawn.
Around then we started seeing those news stories of long midnight lines outside Walmart and the other “big box” stores that led to fistfights over bargain-priced flat-screen TVs and video games, then riots and arrests. The spirit of the Pilgrims retreated to the high-school history books, maybe not even there. You can find something about it on Wikipedia.

We wondered last week about Thanksgiving 2021. We were looking at a quiet one. We called a few restaurants about reservations—all booked, we waited too long. We looked at the ads of local grocery stores describing their take-home Thanksgiving dinners: pick this “side,” or that one to go with a turkey breast, then show up at the store Wednesday to pick up your boxes of dinner for reheating at home. We passed.
I had a thought. An older guy, though probably younger than me, lives by himself up the street. He often sits in a lawn chair on his driveway next to one of those store-bought firepits, chain-smoking and waving at cars and pedestrians. We stopped by on a walk weeks ago and introduced ourselves. “I’m Steve,” he said, inhaling, with a faint smile. “Nice to meet you. My wife passed on in February.” A dozen butts littered the driveway.
I tried to guess what he thought about while he sat there, smoking and waving. Family? Childhood? How he landed in this town? He’s bounced around, Columbia, Charleston, a few other places. He said he has a brother in Missouri. He’s got some health problems, which I guessed have something to do with the smoking. We hung around for a while listening to his stories, then said so long. The next evening he was out there again. We waved, he waved.
I wondered if Steve would be free for Thanksgiving dinner at our place. He seemed to have time on his hands. I walked up the block and stopped in front of his house. His lawn chair was in its usual spot. I rang the doorbell and waited. A dog barked just inside the door. Then somewhere else in the house a second dog barked, a hollow, faraway sound. No answer at the door.
I waited, then rang again, then stepped over and peered through a window at the kitchen, barely visible in the late-afternoon light. The counters were cluttered with miscellaneous stuff, bottles, boxes, utensils. The dogs barked again. A woman walked out of the house next door. “Have you seen Steve?” I called. “No. Haven’t seen him in a few days,” she answered. “He’s usually sitting in that chair on the driveway.” I nodded. “Probably too cold for that,” I said. I waited a few more moments. He could be at his brother’s, I guessed. I turned and looked at the door, then headed home.