February 26, 2024
Millions of people turned 75 in September 1938, as I did yesterday. That month British Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain created his sad legacy when, after three meetings with Hitler, he announced that he and the Fuhrer, in Munich, Germany, had achieved “peace in our time.” The two leaders, one naive, the other ruthless, agreed along with France and fascist Italy that Nazi Germany should annex a huge chunk of Czechoslovakia.
Germany had already seized Austria. As initial negotiations on Czechoslovakia went nowhere, Hitler threatened to invade the country. The British government began to prepare for war. On September 29 the Czech government bowed to the political pressure. The next day at 1:30 AM the Munich Agreement was reached.
Czechoslovakia ceded its Sudentenland region to Germany. Later that day Chamberlain asked Hitler to sign a statement that the PM said was “symbolic of the desire of our two countries never to go to war with one another again.” Hitler signed.
On returning to Britain that same day Chamberlain made his tragic “peace in our time” speech. He was welcomed by the Brits as a hero who had kept the country out of war. A few months later, in March 1939, Hitler broke his promise to respect Czechoslovakia’s sovereignty and German troops occupied the rest of the country. In August Germany and the USSR signed a non-aggression pact. On September 1 Germany and the Soviets invaded Poland, starting World War II.
Through the decades the names “Chamberlain” and “Munich” have become synonymous with the shameful term, “appeasement.”
Today, on the first day of my 76th year, the Republican-controlled House of Representatives is in recess, ignoring a bill passed by the Senate by a 70-29 vote to provide $60 billion in military aid to Ukraine, 90 percent of which would be spent in the U.S.
Saturday, the 24th, was the second anniversary of the Russia’s invasion of Ukraine that, if successful, will position Russian forces on the borders of four of America’s NATO allies. Russia continues to rain missiles on Ukraine’s cities, slaughtering innocents. The Republicans refuse to support funding for Ukraine because they say they’re focused on “border security.”
The poverty-stricken migrants crossing the southern border aren’t launching missiles and rockets at U.S. cities.
Turning 75 means I’m older than most people I know. Those of us in our eighth decade don’t know everything, but we remember lots of things. Folks who grew up in the second half of the twentieth century witnessed a vast scope of human tragedy unfold: in Vietnam, Cambodia, Central America, the Middle East, Central Africa. Then Iran. Then the Middle East again. Then Iraq. Then Afghanistan.
Some of these crises burned out, some have reignited. But the baseline threat to American security for 46 years was confrontation with the Soviet Union. Two months after I was born, in April 1949, the Western powers established NATO as the bulwark of defense against the Soviet-led Warsaw Pact in Central Europe. The USSR imploded in 1991. Thirty-one countries now are NATO members. They face the Russian Federation led by the dictator who launched the Ukraine war, with all its atrocity and brutality.
John Bolton, Trump’s third National Security Adviser, reports in his powerful memoir, “The Room Where It Happened,” that Trump as president viewed NATO as a transactional arrangement based on members’ financial contribution, set at 2 percent of GNP. Because some members didn’t reach that benchmark, he threatened again and again to withdraw the U.S. from NATO. That began at the NATO 2017 Brussels summit, five years before the Alliance stepped up to buttress Ukraine’s defense.
Trump is back with the same threats, applause lines for Republicans (and others) who ignore or belittle America’s historic leadership of the Western alliance. They see easy votes among Americans angry at non-White poor people on our southern doorstep. They’re listening, not to the Ukrainian troops as they run out of bullets, but to the Trump cadre who don’t care about America’s traditional role in defending Western security.
In mid-month the Ukrainian military leadership conceded that Ukraine’s troops had withdrawn from the eastern front town of Avdiivka because of lack of ammunition. The Carnegie Endowment and Ukrainian sources in the field estimate that Russian artillery is firing at five times the rate as the Ukrainians.
Unverified Ukraine military sources said that from October 10, 2023 to February 17, 2024, Russia lost more than 47,000 men, 364 tanks, and about 750 armored fighting vehicles in the assault on Avdiivka. But the Russians keep coming.
America in the 1930s was scarred by tragedy. The country and the world lived through the Great Depression, which destroyed millions of jobs. U.S. unemployment exceeded 25 percent in 1933. Nazi and Communist sympathizers infected the country, including the federal government. But Americans lost interest in the world. Nazi Germany and fascist Italy seemed very far away. Japan may as well have been on another planet, although the Roosevelt administration knew better.
The isolationists had no problem with Hitler, Mussolini, Tojo. They found easier targets in Jews, Catholics, immigrants.
House Speaker Michael Johnson, on Trump’s orders, pounds his fist for border security. The Republican conference has fallen in line. Some of us have seen it before. “Appeasement” became an uncomfortable word when Chamberlain’s agreement revealed its tragedy eleven months later. The Chamberlain legacy, the stench of Munich, is still potent. It is in the air again.
For my birthday, family and friends gathered to launch me into a misty future, touching and sustaining me for the ride. Let’s hope and pray for a birthday wish: courage, forbearance, faith, for ourselves, and for those suffer, as history repeats itself.