November 1, 2021
Like everyone else, we heard about the covid boosters. They’re now available everywhere to the over-65 set and younger folks with health problems, six months after the second vaccination. The booster is supposed give a fresh dose of protection. That’s a good thing, now that hardly anyone is wearing masks.
I got an appointment at a nearby CVS. A younger man waited ahead of me. He, the store employees, and I wore masks, the only ones in the place who did. The nurse called the man’s name. She explained that right now the booster is only for old folks or those with health problems. “I can give you a tetanus shot,” she said. The fellow said OK. The nurse congratulated him as she pressed a band-aid over the needle mark. She called my name, I slid into the chair, she chatted as she stuck me and filled out the card. I waited five minutes and was out of there.
Seeing the young guy cheered me up. If there’s one out there, there must be more. That is, a constituency of truth about health care that dissents from the South Carolina governor’s notion that vaccination or no vaccination are equally reasonable choices, and that all that mumbo-jumbo about covid deaths is just liberal propaganda. But Gov. McMaster’s message is preached everywhere.
We are past the point of getting anywhere by rattling off the sad statistics. But covid keeps killing people, and not just adults. In mid-September 5.7 million children had been infected nationwide. South Carolina led the nation in numbers of schoolchildren with covid. In a grim article early last month reported from Grundy County, Tenn., The Washington Post found that only 17 percent of children 12-17 in Tennessee had been vaccinated, against 56 percent nationwide. In Grundy it was 6 percent.

The article noted that the county health department’s website does not mention the virus or vaccination sites. It quoted a retired teacher who said, “I’m worried sick about our community and our schools. … You have to be very careful about who you have a conversation with. People get angry and you can’t carry on a conversation. There’s too much anger involved.”
I paid attention because Sandy and I took our grandsons to Tennessee in June, before the delta variant showed up and things seemed to be improving. We spent time in Franklin County, where Sandy grew up, but drove over to Grundy, which is next door. Pretty spot. But I noticed not a mask anywhere.
Too much anger, the teacher said. Last year we heard about ugly confrontations at Wal-Marts, restaurants, and elsewhere between customers and employees. A security guard was killed at a Michigan store when he tried to enforce the mask rule. The fight then moved to school boards, defenders of mandates versus anti-maskers, anti-vaxxers.
The pandemic hangs on, thanks in great share to McMasters, Lee in Tennessee, Reeves in Mississippi, DeSantis in Florida, and so on, and the legislators who support them. They tapdance around a notion of “liberty” and “personal responsibility” that enthralls folks who think they recall hearing somewhere that “liberty” or “freedom” mean their personal priorities come ahead of others’ rights. That is, self outweighs community. People who think this way are those who believe someone, President Biden, the CDC, the state health department, is trying to force them to get vaccinated. And where do they get off trying to take away our freedom?
We’ve been given a front-row seat on a national tragedy: the failure of millions of Americans to learn, in school or at home, a fundamental principle that must govern civilized society: that liberty, if it exists, implies correlative obligations. I am “free” only insofar as my freedom to choose how I live doesn’t impinge on or endanger the welfare of others. Another flavor is “conscience,” the idea that if I believe in my heart that I don’t want to get vaccinated, I get a pass to risk endangering others.
We can only guess how deeply this failure of elementary civics education afflicts America. Covid has brought it into high relief. The virulent transmissibility of the covid virus endangers any unvaccinated person who comes in contact with it. We’ve surpassed by a hundred thousand the 1918-1920 Spanish influenza toll of 675,000 Americans.
Nationwide, the mask thing is pretty much over with, except at doctor’s offices, hospitals, airports, and aboard planes. In the Northeast, where upwards of 70 percent have been vaccinated, people are beginning to feel safe. In the South and elsewhere it’s a different story. Mask mandates for schoolchildren, meant to protect the kids, rile the folks who still think Trump won the election.
The “masks required” signs are gone. A store in Brevard, N.C., offers a 5 percent discount for either wearing masks or showing proof of vaccination. But the public is done with masks. I’ve noticed, when I’m wearing a mask, people look at me strangely. The numbers of vaccinations are growing, but painfully slowly. The docs advise that unvaccinated people still should wear them.
But the unvaccinated are not wearing them. They’re not wearing them because they don’t believe the scientists, the epidemiologists who have studied viruses and their pathologies for years—for decades, some of them. The Grundy folks aren’t shy with their opinions: they don’t trust the vaccine, it was rushed, it’s the Democrats and Biden. I ask: we know where Fauci and NIH head Francis Collins went to college. Where did you get your medical degree?
The Founding Fathers demanded liberty from King George, Jefferson wrote about it in the Declaration, the Constitution safeguards it, our servicemen and women stand guard worldwide to defend it. How did it mutate into willingness to risk infecting others with a deadly disease?
Sandy is set for her booster on Thursday, and hopes the line won’t be too long. Maybe the guy ahead of me will show up again. Maybe he’ll bring his friends. Maybe those Grundy County folks, and their friends in this town, will figure out why those scientists tell them to get vaccinated. And get over the anger.