June 2, 2025
Sometimes unique moments—odd maybe, but unique—don’t involve going anywhere or doing anything. At the back of the Flying Fox coffee shop in downtown Greer a young man stared at his laptop. That wasn’t unusual. He tapped at the keyboard. Also on the table: a thick paperback entitled Plotinus. That was unusual.
From a long-ago grad school course I recalled Plotinus, the third-century Greek philosopher associated with the term “Neoplatonism,” a revival of the thinking of Plato. Sitting nearby, I finished my coffee. “Reading Plotinus?” I asked.
He looked up, surprised. “Not right now. But I will be,” he answered. “Plotinus’s thought is related to that of an earlier philosopher, Origen.”
Origen was a complicated, controversial figure of the second century, when early Christian scholars were debating what the Christian religion stood for.
“Grad school?”
“No, I’m taking an RTS course online. RTS—Reformed Theological Seminary, in Charlotte,” he said. He answered my next question before I asked. “And no, I’m not planning on the ministry.”
Had he been studying engineering, computer science, business, or marketing I wouldn’t have noticed. But as he sipped his coffee he read philosophy and religion. He had longish hair pulled back in a braid, a wispy beard, and wore a plaid lumberjack shirt. I knew to move on. “Good luck,” I said.
Plotinus—why not? The braided fellow wasn’t the first guy or gal to read philosophy in a coffee shop, just the first I’ve seen. Most coffee shops allow laptoppers to sit for hours as long as they keep buying drinks, sometimes even if they don’t. In the same place a young woman in a long dress balanced a textbook on her keyboard and scribbled in a notebook. Another girl next to her read a thick book.
You can “google” Plotinus and be drawn into the crosscurrents of early philosophical and religious thinking that eventually, 1,000 and more years after him, formed the intellectual foundation of Western civilization.
At home, I thought of my grad-school days. I recalled, with a lot of gaps, the lessons I picked up while reading in the same currents. The early Christian thinkers, called Patristics, who lived between the first and eighth centuries, studied the Gospels to meld faith and philosophy in concepts like the divinity of Christ; the meaning of the incarnation; the nature of Baptism, and on through the pantheon of Christian belief.
They were men, today mostly forgotten, with names that ring oddly off modern ears: Origen, Athanasius, Ireneus, Ignatius, Polycarp, Justin Martyr. Then Clement of Alexandria, Basil, Gregory Nazienzus, Hilary of Poitiers, many others, who created the path for Saint Augustine of Hippo.
Augustine (354-430) is the patron of the Augustinians, the religious order to which the brand-new pope, Leo XIV, belongs. He also wrote two of Christianity’s great declarations, Confessions and The City of God. His work, along with the scholarship of Dominican monk Thomas Aquinas of the 13th century, reconciled Christian faith with Greek philosophy.
The evolution of philosophy integrated with religious faith continued through the middle ages, inspired by St. Anselm of Canterbury, St. Albertus Magnus, Aquinas, and other priest-philosophers, among them John Duns Scotus and St. Bonaventure, who drew on Aristotle and other classical thinkers. They debated and refined intellectual arguments supporting Christian doctrine, accepted by some, rejected by others.
The Protestant Reformation that exploded in 1517, set off by Martin Luther, transformed Christianity forever. In 1536 John Calvin published his Institutes of the Christian Religion; the Catholic Council of Trent (1545-1563) repudiated Protestantism; in 1611 the Church of England published the King James Bible. In Central Europe the Protestant-Catholic Thirty Years War killed millions.

Catholic property was seized, priests executed. England’s Lord Protector Oliver Cromwell led a brutal war against the Catholic Irish.
Protestantism, which the coffee-shop guy is studying, continued to evolve in Europe and America over generations, based on shades of distinctions in faithfulness to the Bible. Catholicism’s Second Vatican Council, 1962 through ’65, produced 16 ground-breaking documents that reaffirmed traditional tenets of belief but modified liturgical practices.
The legacy of organized religion in America isn’t pure. Fundamentalist preachers through two centuries thundered from their pulpits that segregation was God’s will.
I wondered about the fellow. He expected privacy, as folks do when they bring their laptops to coffee shops. But in that cramped public place his mind was somewhere else, searching for knowledge and insight in the first or second century after Christ.
Maybe he’s on to something at this low point in American history: a path to rise above the bleakness and low-life grubbiness of daily national news. One answer: ponder higher things, the subtle nuances of religious truth and spirituality born two millennia ago.
If we look around we’ll find others looking for answers, studying the impact of great thinkers on their lives and beliefs. They may find questions that create doubt, that undermine or destroy lifelong assumptions. They may make excruciating discoveries about themselves, about truth, that lead them to faith and sustain them in today’s world. You may see them in coffee shops. And everywhere.




