May 27, 2024
In September 1973 I was on leave after a yearlong tour on Okinawa with the Marine Corps. I drove from my folks’ home in New Jersey out to Madison, Wisc., to visit a friend who then was a graduate student at the University of Wisconsin.
As I walked across the campus to meet him, I ran into a group protesting the school’s use of non-union lettuce in the dining hall. Some of them, I could see, clearly were not students. They noticed my Marine Corps haircut, impossible to miss in that crowd, and opened fire with barrages of curses. “Fascist!” was one of the milder ones. I said nothing and hurried past, quick-time.
Fifty-one years have passed. And now, on Memorial Day, I wonder about those people. What have they been thinking all these years? Then I move on from the thought, as if it didn’t matter. But it does matter.
So many Memorial Days have passed, burying the rancor of the 1960s and early 1970s. Since Vietnam America’s men and women under arms remained on call: Lebanon, where 241 Marines died in the 1983 terrorist bombing, Iraq 1991, Afghanistan 2001, Iraq again in 2003, then still Afghanistan.
War never ends, which is why Memorial Day matters. Americans willing to fight for their country keep making that ultimate sacrifice, right now, in places many civilians can’t find on a map: Niger, Syria, the Gulf of Aden. Americans guard the free world.
It is a day for solemnity. At Quantico National Cemetery and at dozens of other sacred places, families gather. Veterans march forward carrying the Stars and Stripes and their ancient unit streamers. All rise. At Quantico the local Marine band plays the national anthem. A senior Marine officer, following tradition, cites the litany of great battles: Gettysburg, Antietam, Belleau Wood, Iwo Jima, Okinawa, Normandy, Bastogne, Khe Sanh, Hue, Fallujah. The list could go on.
The climactic moment is the silent one, when a bugler pipes a solo “Taps.” Marines raise their weapons and fire the ages-old salvo in salute to those interred at that sacred place, and all such places.
Through American history some 1,064,000 American servicemen and women have given their lives, from the Revolution to the present, including combat and non-combat deaths, but not including 290,000 Confederate deaths during the Civil War. In 1917 for the first time, Americans fought in Europe. Twenty-three years later the country began to recognize its new role, defined by FDR nearly a year before Pearl Harbor as the “arsenal of democracy.”
In the decades since 1945 America stepped up further. The U.S led the establishment of NATO in 1949. Through the Cold War and even while Vietnam burned hot, thousands of U.S soldiers waited in Europe for a Soviet attack. Now Europe is again at the brink, with Ukraine in a death struggle against Russia, which under Putin has reincarnated the USSR.
The nation moved to an all-volunteer force in January 1973 when the draft was ended. Today America’s active-duty armed forces stand at 1.2 million. Another 766,000 serve in reserve components.
That may not be enough. Korea is a powder keg. The Peoples’ Republic of China, the PRC, is threatening Taiwan. Japan, Australia, and other Pacific allies are on edge. Army teams are operating in Central Africa. In the Middle East, the Navy and Air Force are trading fire with terrorists. War never ends.
The U.S. Navy today counts 296 deployable ships. In 2016 it said it needed 355. This past March it increased the number required to 381. Under a best-case scenario, the 381 goal won’t be reached until 2042.

Good people can debate the services’ roles and the numbers of personnel needed to fulfill their missions. They can dispute the rightness of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, and question the scope of the America’s role in the world. That is already happening. Senior leaders can trade theories about the right number of Navy ships and types of ships.
What does not change is the ideal of service, the calling of the American under arms, and with it, the honoring of the immortal ones who have given their lives in the jungles, on the beaches, and across the deserts of the world.
At the cemeteries, service personnel and volunteers have placed American flags at each grave. Following the ceremonies, autos line up to pass through. Family members place flowers and mementoes before their loved one’s headstone or marker. They may stand or kneel for a while. Fathers, mothers, sons, and daughters who lie at rest are remembered and honored. That is the way it should be, and must be, on Memorial Day.



