May 1, 2023
“Good fences make good neighbors,” Robert Frost wrote in “The Mending Wall.” As in the poem, every so often something has to be done about them. Our white picket fence surrounds the backyard, with gates on both sides of the house. In fact it is no longer white, but dappled with dark mold. Time for a new fence.
This is what we do in the burbs: replace, upgrade, invent. People in apartments are limited to painting, buying new furniture, rearranging it. Same with condos and townhouses: restricted to the space between their outer walls. Homeowners who are captains of their own plots can add decks, patios, treehouses, swingsets, lawn ornaments. We can try to recreate our visions, or our illusions, of class, taste, comfort. Sometimes it’s a struggle. We can make our property beautiful or tacky. HOA covenants may prevent painting the house purple or parking a giant boat in the driveway. They may or may not.
The fence on the rear border of our Virginia home was a good neighbor, a few strands of wire that marked the property line, invisible from the house. The backyard was a steep hill; we could look up past the fence at the large lots of homes on the street above ours. The impression, somehow, was a dreamy rural scene, the homes resembling barns sitting on a lush hillside.
Our South Carolina fence, made of cheap, bendable vinyl, follows an easement along the property line on two sides. To the north it faces the next-door neighbor’s eight-foot-high wall that blocks any view of his yard. Along the back is a tall wire fence, allowing a view of the wide, pretty yard on the next street. The backyard of the neighbor to the south, a middle-aged Cuban man who found asylum in the U.S., is bounded only by our fence, allowing an occasional glimpse of him sunbathing in his Speedo in warm weather.
Since our fence is out of sight of the street and other bills kept coming in, we let it go over these past two years. But recently a ten-foot section fell over into the yard. I tried to refasten it to the adjoining sections, but the next morning it was again on the ground.
A block away from our place a team of men worked on a sturdy-looking new fence. We walked over and talked to the foreman, Brandon, about a new wood picket fence. He handed me a business card. We filled out the HOA paperwork, approval took a month. We called Brandon, he came by, measured our fence, and sent us an estimate. It looked reasonable.
It’s common sense that when you decide to hire a contractor you want at least a second quote, maybe a third. Everyone looks to compare prices, services offered, and that hard-to-define quality—personality, maybe, is the word. You want to feel comfortable with the people you hire. You shop around, learn the market. Still, cost matters. The low bid usually wins.

We found another fence guy on the internet, Rusty. He came by and, like Brandon, measured the fence and showed us photos of his work. He impressed us as a competent, experienced professional. His fences all looked attractive and sturdy. Rusty’s estimate, two days later, came within $75.00 of Brandon’s. But Brandon had said he’d haul away the old fence at no charge. We realized we had forgotten to ask either of them about painting and sealing the fence; raw, untreated wood in this climate would start to rot in two years. Brandon guessed $400 to $500 for painting, Rusty estimated $800.
Brandon offered a $300 discount if we paid cash. I liked the discount but wondered: does cash, for him, mean straight currency, like out of the ATM?
Doing business should mean creating transaction records through use of checks and credit, not stacks of greenbacks. So “cash” meaning a pile of currency raises a red flag. The contractor who pays his employees in cash to allow them to avoid reporting the income is tiptoeing along the shady side of the law. If he accepts a check he’d have to deposit or cash it, creating a transaction. Getting hard currency from clients would let him avoid that.
Brandon said he’d take a check but then the discount would only be $150. His $500 painting estimate was only a guess, likely it would run higher. Rusty is waiting in the wings with his $800 painting estimate.
The fence rebuild had become more complicated than I expected. Getting our Virginia house painted nearly three years ago meant getting three bids and going with the lowest. Then we felt pressure to get it done, get out of town, get on with life. Now, I’m used to our collapsing, worn-out fence. Time is speeding by. Other plans, other distractions, are crowding in. Do we really need to do this? Unless we have a yard party, no one sees the fence. We could use the fence budget for other things.
Yet the broken segment and the cracked and wobbly pickets seem to stare at me. We had put this off long enough. After years of do-it-myself projects we needed to hire a pro, admire his skilled labor, check “fence” off our list of must-do projects, and maybe get to the hope-to-do list. But $800 for painting?
Can it be that hard? I’ve painted lots of walls and stained a deck. We could get the paint at Home Depot. We don’t have a timetable or deadline. I could daub the undersides of the pickets, Sandy could do the edges. The flat sides would be easy.
Why does fence-painting ring a bell? Right: Mark Twain’s classic, The Adventures of Tom Sawyer. When Tom’s Aunt Polly caught him skipping school she ordered him to whitewash her fence. Instead he tricked other boys into doing it. We have two grandsons. They remind me, sometimes, of junior versions of Tom and his sidekick, Huck Finn. We’d pay them something. Not $800.





